Survivor Bias in India: Why Celebrating Winners Alone Can Mislead You

 In India, success stories are everywhere — from rags-to-riches entrepreneurs like Dhirubhai Ambani and Ritesh Agarwal, to IIT toppers who crack UPSC and land top government jobs, to cricketers like Virat Kohli making the nation proud. We love these stories because they inspire us, fuel ambition, and show us what’s possible.

But here’s the catch — when we only focus on winners and success stories, we fall prey to a cognitive trap called survivor bias. This bias can distort how we view success, effort, and the risks involved. Let’s unpack what survivor bias means and why, in the Indian context, being aware of it is crucial.

---

What Is Survivor Bias?

Survivor bias happens when we look only at the “survivors” — those who succeeded — and ignore those who tried the same path but didn’t make it. The failures, struggles, and silent exits remain invisible. This skews our understanding because the visible winners are only a small, unrepresentative sample of everyone who started.

For example:

• We read about Indian startup founders who became billionaires, but thousands of startups never take off or shut down.

• We celebrate the IIT graduate who built a successful tech company, but don’t often hear about those IIT grads struggling to find jobs.

• We admire a cricketer who played for India, but overlook the countless talented players who never got a chance.

---

Why Is This a Problem?

1. False Perception of Success Probability

If you only see winners, you might overestimate how likely success is, leading to unrealistic expectations. For instance, many young Indians aspire to start their own business inspired by Flipkart’s success, without realizing that about 90% of startups fail.

2. Ignoring the Role of Luck and Timing

Success isn’t just hard work or talent; often, luck and timing play huge roles. Survivor bias hides this, making success look purely due to skill or effort.

3. Underestimating Risks and Challenges

By focusing on success stories, people might underestimate the risks or challenges. This can lead to poor decisions — like dropping out of college thinking it’s a shortcut, inspired by a handful of famous dropout billionaires.

---

Is Highlighting Winners Bad?

Absolutely not! Celebrating achievers motivates society, spreads hope, and shows what’s possible. India thrives on its success stories to inspire millions.

The key is balance: Along with winners, we must recognize the silent majority who struggled or failed. This balanced view helps us understand the true path to success — which often involves failures, retries, and learning.

---

How Can We Avoid Survivor Bias?

1. Listen to Failure Stories

Entrepreneurs should share their failures, not just wins. Educational institutions can highlight students’ struggles, not just toppers.

2. Be Realistic About Success Rates

Understand that for every successful startup or athlete, many tried and failed. Don’t underestimate the odds.

3. Acknowledge Luck and External Factors

Recognize that timing, connections, and external circumstances matter too.

4. Learn from the Whole Spectrum

Study success and failure cases to get a realistic roadmap.

---

Examples from India

• Startup Scene: While Ola and Paytm are celebrated, thousands of startups quietly shut down each year. Recognizing this prepares aspiring founders better.

• Competitive Exams: UPSC toppers are applauded, but most aspirants clear preliminary exams only after multiple attempts or never at all. Coaching institutes could emphasize this reality more.

• Sports: Cricket legends shine on TV, but countless players play at club and district level without ever getting a big break.

---

Conclusion

Survivor bias is a natural cognitive shortcut but being aware of it is vital — especially in a country like India where success stories inspire millions. Celebrate winners, yes, but also recognize the invisible struggles and failures that paint the full picture.

This balanced perspective empowers smarter decisions, more realistic expectations, and a healthier appreciation of what success really entails.

No Second Chances: The Silent Brutality of Dreaming in a Developing Country

 In a developing country, you don’t chase dreams—you gamble with your life.

You’re told from childhood to dream big. Become an IAS officer. Crack IIT. Be a doctor. Change the nation. But what no one tells you is this: you only get one real shot. Miss it, and the world moves on without you. The scaffolding beneath your dreams—money, time, mental health, support—is so fragile, it barely holds through a single attempt.

There’s no cushion here. No "gap year" safety. No second-chance scholarships. No mental health leave. If you fail, you're not just a student who didn't make it—you're a liability. A burden on your family. A cautionary tale whispered in relatives’ homes. A cracked hope your younger siblings learn to avoid.

In developed countries, people change careers at 35 and still find jobs. They fail at startups, write about it, and get investor funding again. They go to therapy, take antidepressants, take a break. Here, you can't afford a break—you barely afford the exam form. You’re told to “keep going” even when your insides are bleeding. You scroll past success stories on LinkedIn while your parents avoid your eyes at dinner.

You can work for five years on one dream. Wake up at 5am, study ten hours a day, cut off friends, relationships, joy. And yet, one bad paper, one missed cut-off, and it’s all gone. No do-over. No extra attempt. Just an invisible stamp on your forehead that says “failure.”

People say “hard work always pays off.” It doesn’t. Not here. Sometimes, the lucky win. Sometimes, the connected. Sometimes, just the well-fed. In the silence of your room, surrounded by notes and self-help quotes, you begin to understand: this country doesn’t reward effort—it rewards outcome.

And the worst part? You can’t even grieve properly. Because somewhere, someone your age is posting their rank. Someone is moving to Delhi for a coaching class you can’t afford. Someone is making your exact dream look easy. And the shame burns deeper than the failure itself.

In a developing country, dreaming is an act of rebellion. But failing is a death sentence. Not literal—just slow, suffocating, and rarely spoken of. No one will tell you this when you start. But if you're reading this after falling, you already know.

Why developed countries often offer more second chances:

1. Safety nets:
   Developed nations tend to have better unemployment benefits, public healthcare, student loan systems, and legal protections. So failing at something—losing a job, dropping out, going bankrupt—is less likely to destroy your entire future.

2. More flexible education and job markets:
   You can go back to school at 35. You can switch careers after failing at one. You can start a business, fail, and still get hired somewhere. These systems expect reinvention.

3. Less stigma:
   Culturally, failure is more normalized—especially in the U.S. or parts of Europe—where entrepreneurship, career pivots, or academic retries are part of the process.

---

🧱 Why second chances are harder in developing countries:

1. Limited opportunities:
   In places like India, the pyramid is steep. One shot at UPSC or IIT or MBBS feels like the only shot. Failing once can often mean falling behind for years.

2. Fewer resources:
   There's often little state support if you fail. No backup loans, mental health support, or accessible re-skilling programs. Family pressure and financial burdens weigh heavier.

3. Societal pressure:
   Failing carries heavier stigma in many developing societies, where status and "settling down early" are cultural expectations.